USEPA Considers Emission Standards for Methane

Craig R. Hedin | Gesell’s Pump Sales & Service, Inc., IOGA Member at Large

In 2015, the United States Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) promulgated a revision of regulations with respect to methane emissions. The approach taken by the EPA was that “one size fits all” with respect to all oil and natural gas operators in the United States. This approach had a disproportional impact on conventional operations such as those in Illinois where the norm is low production wells and small business operators.

Prior to 2015, the EPA had promulgated regulations to address Volatile Organic Compounds (VOCs). The regulations addressed storage vessels with the Potential to Emit (PTE) the VOCs in an amount equal to or greater than six tons per years. VOCs are organic chemicals that have a high vapor pressure at ordinary room temperatures. If the regulations are applicable, an operator with respect to a tank battery in a conventional operation must reduce VOC emissions by 95% by a control device or establish an alternative mass based emissions limit. There are also requirements for compliance monitoring, record keeping, and reporting requirements for various control devices.

The regulatory revisions issued in 2015 set forth standards to reduce emissions of methane as to well operations. This would have been in addition to the procedures to reduce VOCs. The regulations included requirements for detecting and repairing methane leaks at oil well sites. Leaks known as “fugitive emissions” can occur at a number of points at an oil well site when connections are not properly fitted, hatches are not properly weighted and sealed, or when seals and gaskets start to deteriorate. The EPA was of the opinion that these leaks could be a significant source of methane emissions in the Industry. The rule did not exempt low production well sites (those with an average combined oil and natural gas production of less than 15 barrels of oil equivalent per well per day). Operators were required to conduct surveys to determine leaks and to undertake repairs. The extent of surveys and the equipment to be utilized was very burdensome and costly to a typical Illinois operator.

Since the advent of the Administration of President Trump, the Industry has advocated for policies to rewrite the methane emission regulations. The EPA has now proposed to change the regulated emission from methane to VOCs. The proposal to change the targeted emissions would give to the EPA the opportunity to fully understand the potential consequences of future options and design those that are necessary to be fair and cost effective to oil and gas operators.

The Industry in Illinois through the Illinois Oil and Gas Association, together with other associations, have submitted comments to the EPA with respect to the revision of regulations as to methane emissions. The substance of the comments is as follows:

  • Various aspects of the methane emission regulations are supported only by politics and not justified under the Clean Air Act. The EPA in 2015 failed to consider the differences between large volumes of production when a well is initially drilled and low volumes when production declines because of the production curve. What is cost effective with initial production is not cost effective when production declines. The EPA was unwilling to recognize the unique economic realities and disproportionate impact of its regulations on low production wells. The failure to provide an exemption to low production wells was based on a single study presented during the comment period and not the consensus of other data supporting the exemption. Furthermore, the EPA failed to comply with the Administrative Procedure Act in promulgating the regulations in that it failed to justify its decision to add methane as a regulated pollutant and its decision to not include the exemption. EPA’s proposed revisions to the rules are simply an attempt to correct the prior errors.
  • The addition of methane sources from the transmission and storage segments of the Industry by the EPA was without legal authority. A source category was first established in 1979 pursuant to a significant contribution finding. The EPA rationalized that the 1979 source category was broad enough to include sources from transmission and storage operations. This was legally insufficient and the sources should be removed. Revisions to the production and processing source category are warranted but only if the low production exemption is recognized and made a subcategory in order to prevent a disproportionate impact. The EPA’s proposal to remove the transmission and storage segments as sources for methane emissions is correct.
  • The Clean Air Act requires the EPA to make a pollutant-specific significant contribution finding before regulating that pollutant as to a source category. It is insufficient that the source category may emit that pollutant. In 1979, the EPA found that hydrocarbons and SO2 from oil and gas production fields were emissions that contributed significantly to air pollution. While methane is a hydrocarbon, in 1979, the EPA was not analyzing methane as a pollutant and to now contend that it did is without basis. The pollutant-specific significant contribution finding required by the Clean Air Act must be conducted prior to promulgating any methane regulations. This finding has never been made.

The EPA will now consider the comments submitted as to the proposed rule. The thrust of the comments from the Illinois Industry and other states is that the existing methane emission rules are too burdensome and expensive and would have the effect of terminating many aspects of the Illinois Industry. While the rules as to VOCs should continue, those as to methane should be limited.

Oil and gas leaders sway high school students to consider a career in the industry

Raven Ford | Tristate Homepage

For most high schoolers working in the oil industry isn’t the first thing that comes to mind as a career choice.

“I want to go to criminal justice to become a police officer and step up to state,” says Brenden Hightshoe, a senior at Carmi County High School.

“Train business or coal loading train operating just like my stepfather.” included Rhider Melvin, also a student at Carmi County High.

Which is why Illinois Petroleum Resources Board executive director Seth Whitehead joined the high school’s teen conference.

According to Whitehead, the oil production industry has long been white county’s leading employer representing seven percent of overall employment.

“I think most folks are aware that the united states is experiencing record-breaking oil production at the moment. this has created a need in the nation for more oil and gas related positions and really the demand is high and also these are good paying jobs as well,” says Whitehead.

However, oil leaders say misconceptions of the industry lead to low interest in the career field.

“I’m sure a lot of folks think that roughnecking or rest about jobs are the only jobs available in the gas and oil industry but there are literally dozens of jobs expanding various skill sets and education levels.”

Although students say they already have a career choice in mind, a future in the oil industry could be an option.

“I got a lot of knowledge on like how they get paid and how the industry is going to jump ad how good the industry is going to sparked some interest in the oil industry. I didn’t know much about it until the presentation,” says Hightshoe.

Oil and natural gas industry employment grew faster than any other sector in 2018 and is projected to do so again this year.


Read More.

In Memory of Clifford Briggs

In Memory of Clifford Briggs (1922 – 2019) who was an inaugural 2007 Indiana Oil and Gas Association Hall of Fall Honoree along with Hugh S. Barger,  Henry R. Gwaltney, James E. Kendall, Lester D. Moore, and C.A. Robison.  Below please find Clifford’s obituary. Indiana Oil and Gas Association Board of Directors extend our deepest sympathies to the Briggs Family.

Clifford Carroll Briggs, 96, of Newburgh and formerly of Mt. Vernon, IN passed away March 19, 2019, at Primrose Memory Care. He was born September 24, 1922, in Browns, IL to the late Otis and Ethel (Fieber) Briggs.

Clifford was a graduate of Albion High School. He had been a medic in the U.S. Army. Clifford was an independent oil producer and was the owner of farming operations. He had been on the Board of Directors for Peoples Bank and Trust for many years. Clifford was a member of the Western Hills Country Club, Elks, and the American Legion. In 2007, he received Inaugural Recognition in the Indiana Oil and Gas Association Hall of Fame. Clifford enjoyed fishing, golfing, gardening and traveling.

He was preceded in death by his sisters, Dorcas Vance, and Geneva Shepherd; and brother, Kenneth Briggs.

He is survived by his wife of 68 years, Kathleen (Wood) Briggs; daughter, Nancy (Ken) Johnson; son, David (Phyliss) Briggs; grandchildren, Scott (Julie) Zenthofer, Jeffrey (Jolene) Zenthofer, Ericson (Kara) Briggs and Jenna (Kevin) Schuchard; great-grandchildren, Cole and Kaitlyn Zenthofer, Lincoln and Everly Briggs and Lane Schuchard; several step-grandchildren and step-great-grandchildren.

Funeral service will be held at 11:00 am on Friday, March 22, 2019, at First United Methodist Church, 601 Main St., Mt. Vernon, IN, with Rev. David Stevens officiating and burial to follow in Bellefontaine Cemetery.

Visitation will be held from 9:00 am until 11:00 am service time on Friday at the church.

Thank you to Primrose Memory Care and Southern Care Hospice for their comforting care.

Memorial contributions may be made to First United Methodist Church.

Condolences may be made online at

Sam Booth

Samuel Calvin Booth, age 76, of Flora, Illinois, passed away Sunday evening, February 24, 2019, at St. John’s Hospital in Springfield.

He was born December 28, 1942, in Olney, the son of Eldon Everett and Alta Mae (Forsythe) Booth.  He was united in marriage to Clara Louise Sparlin on January 31, 1964, sharing 55 years of marriage.

Sam graduated from Cisne High School and attended Southern Illinois University.  He was the owner and operator of Booth Resources Inc.

Sam is survived by his wife, Clara Booth of Flora; 2 sons, Calvin Booth and wife Robin, and Anthony Booth and wife Judy, both of Flora; 4 grandchildren, Brittany Booth and fiancé Dillon Holloway of Champaign, Ashley Booth of Champaign, and Avery and Quincy Booth, both of Flora; a brother, Marcus Pat Booth of Flora; and special friends including Dave Johnson and Barb Milligan.

He was preceded in death by his parents and a brother, Charles E. Booth.

A funeral service will begin at 3 p.m. Friday, March 1, 2019, at Frank & Bright Funeral Home in Flora.  A committal service will follow at Elmwood Cemetery.  Visitation will be Thursday evening from 5 until 7 p.m. at the funeral home.  In lieu of flowers, memorial donations are appreciated towards any charity of the donor’s choice, and these will be accepted through the funeral home.

Marion County oil industry continues to pump needed funding for local schools

Seth Whitehead | Centralia Sentinel

Most folks in the Sa­lem area are prob­ably familiar with the dozens of ‘.’nodding donkeys” that dot the coun­tryside throughout Marion County. After all, these iconic oilfield contraptions have been pumping “black gold” in Marion County for decades.

But some folks may not be aware that they are also are literally pumping mil­lions of needed funds into the county’s public school systems.

Illinois oil production is assessed and taxed as real estate, similar to property taxes paid on a residential home. All of the revenue collected from this tax stays at the local level and goes directly to support the areas where oil is pro­duced: counties, villages, townships, cities, and most importantly, local schools.


In Marion County – which has been the state’s No. 2 oil producer in recent years – this tax generated $9.2 million in revenue from 2007 to 2013, accord­ing toa,2016 RCF Economic & Financial Consultingeco­nomic impact report. More than half of that revenue went to fund Marion County public schools.”

All told, ad valorem tax revenue from Illinois oil production generated $57.4 million in revenue for the state’s 40-plus oil produc­ing counties from 2007
to 2013. This revenue is absolutely critical, not only because Illinois public schools rely on local prop­erty tax revenue for more than 60 percent of their funding, but also because those schools simply can­not rely on our infamously debt-crippled state govern­ment to meet its relatively meager education funding obligations.

Illinois ranks dead last in public school funding that comes from the state. And due in large part to a pension crisis, that already inadequate public school funding has been pro-rated at 89 percent in recent years, placing even more burden at the local level, where too much has been asked in the first place.

This is just one example of why Illinois’ oil production industry is so important to the state – a fact upstate “Keep It In the Ground” activists should keep in mind the next time they suggest the oil industry should be done away with entirely.

For more on the Illinois oil industry’s contributions to the state’s economy, check out RCF Economic & Financial Consulting’s economic impact report.

Seth Whitehead, Executive Director Illinois Petroleum Resources Board

Veteran ‘oilmen’ show LCC museum

Tom Compton | Crawford County Daily News

The newest class of Leadership Crawford County recently had the opportunity to learn about Illinois and Crawford County’s oil history at the Oblong Oil Field Museum.

The visit included a personalized tour by longtime oil man John Larrabee of Larrabee OilCo., Oblong. Larrabee has been a longtime promoter and contributor to the museum. Also speaking to the group were Seth Whitehead and Sam Barbee.

Whitehead is the new executive director of the Illinois Petroleum Resources Board. Whitehead comes to the IPRB after a four-and-a-half-year stint at FTI Consulting, where he was most recently Team Lead of Energy in Depth, a research and education campaign focused on media outreach with regard to shale development across the country.

A 2003 graduate of Southern Illinois University-Carbondale and native of Fayette County, Whitehead’s duties at the IPRB will include serving as the primary media contact for the upstream Illinois oil industry.

The IPRB was formed in 1998 to provide public awareness/education programs and to clean up/restore abandoned oilfield sites throughout the state. Funding for IPRB programs comes from voluntary contributions of oil and natural gas producers and royalty owners in Illinois.

Larrabee pointed out that the IPRB played a big part in loaning money for the construction of the Oil Field Museum buildings.

Sam Barbee is the executive vice president of the Illinois Oil and Gas Association. IOGA is a group of oil and gas producers, landowners, royalty owners, service providers, and others in the Illinois area. They advocate for oil and gas producers in Illinois and provide networking opportunities for the industry.

Read More.

Energy Makes Holiday Season Bright

Edward Cross, President | Kansas Independent Oil & Gas Association

December 17, 2018

Before the holidays, many of us will search for the perfect gifts for loved ones. What many don’t realize, however, is that nearly every one of us will either give or receive the gift of petroleum this holiday season.

When talking about petroleum, most people likely have the image of a barrel filled with a black gooey substance, or at best, a gift card for your local gas station, neither of which seems like an ideal holiday gift. But, what I’m talking about and what most people do not realize is that petroleum is part of some of the most popular gifts, from the iPad, or TV on the top of your wish list, to the many gifts asked for by children in letters to Santa.

When thinking about the role of oil and gas in our lives, most people look only as far as their vehicles and the price of gasoline, but petroleum plays an integral role in nearly every aspect of our lives. Oil-based products are likely the first thing you touch at the beginning and end of each day, whether it is your alarm clock, television remote, iPhone, or even the toothpaste and toothbrush you use to brush your teeth. Those who wear make-up or synthetic fibers, such as polyester or nylon, are using or touching petroleum nearly 24 hours a day, and, as a key component in heart valves, seat belts, helmets, life vests, and even Kevlar, petroleum is saving tens of thousands of lives daily. Furthermore, oil and gas are improving our living environments by heating our homes in the winter, cooling them in the summer, and keeping our lights on and petroleum-based gadgets fully charged.

These are just a few of the improvements that oil and gas makes in our lives and societies around the world. And, in the same way that we take great pride in our agriculture sector and the role it plays in feeding people around the world, we should also take great pride in the role our oil and gas industry plays in providing a commodity essential to our very way of life.

Affordable energy is essential for almost every aspect of our modern lives. Without it, we wouldn’t have many of the things we often take for granted. Affordable energy is needed to run hospitals and laboratories that improve our health. It’s required to deliver electricity to our homes and put fuel in our vehicles. It also supports millions of jobs associated with all of these things and more.

This year (2018) will go down as another year of historic growth of oil production and opportunity across the nation. We should take a moment to recognize the incredible impact our oil and gas industry has had on our state, our nation, and the world. The technologies and innovations developed here in America to unleash our abundant oil and natural gas reserves are bringing us closer to energy independence.

Our nation’s energy abundance can be used to lift people up. More than a billion people around the world face challenges for adequate food and education, clean water and protection from heat and cold due to lack of access to energy. We should work to ensure more people have access to safe, affordable, and reliable energy, no matter which state, nation, or continent they reside. Because to rise out of poverty and enjoy health and safety, people need more energy, not less.

As an industry, we are proud to produce a resource that is used to fuel the airplanes and vehicles that will bring families together this holiday season; the resource that will go into the gifts that will be exchanged; and the resource that is bringing us closer to energy independence.

On behalf of the oil and gas industry, we wish you all a happy holiday season.

U.S. becomes net exporter of petroleum, Illinois oil production remains steady

Brook Schyler | WSIL

For the first time in nearly 75 years, the United States has become a net exporter of petroleum, which consists of crude oil and natural gas liquids.

Seth Whitehead, Executive Director of the Illinois Petroleum Resource board, says shale drilling in places such as Texas and New Mexico, over the past ten years, is mainly responsible for the breakthrough in petroleum.

Although there’s no shale drilling in Illinois, oil production is still a major part of the economy. The state’s oil wells pump 8-9 million barrels of crude oil annually. That’s just one day’s worth of crude oil production for the entire country.

“It’s a small piece of the pie, but the impact that our small industry has on the state is anything but small,” Whitehead says.

Illinois has about 650 oil fields, mostly located in the southern part of the state. Whitehead says the industry directly employs 4,000 workers, mostly in White and Lawrence counties.

Read More & Watch Interview.

Lester D. Moore

Lester D. Moore, a leader, and advocate for the oil and gas industry on both the local and national level, passed away on October 27, 2018. Lester was born October 12, 1933, in the small hamlet of Ellery which is located in both Edwards and Wayne Counties, Illinois. He grew up on a small farm where life was a challenge. Lester told of a friend who stated that he was in good shape when he got a new piece of cardboard to put inside his shoes.

After graduating from Edwards County High School, Lester traveled to Champaign to attend the University of Illinois where he graduated with a Petroleum Engineering Degree. Upon graduation, he entered the Schlumberger training program but then was drafted into the Navy where he spent two years in the Civil Engineering Corps. In 1957 he arrived in Evansville to work for Barger Engineering from 1957 to 1960 and then Campbell and Rickman from 1960 to 1967, both petroleum engineering firms. He soon struck out on his own to seek work as an oil consultant. He worked with operators and gained valuable experience in the industry, especially with secondary recovery operations. With the downturn in the industry in the 1960s, he decided to pursue development and operations for himself. The first few months were tough with Lester stating “I remember that the books had less than one page in them – the entire entry of expense and income.” Like all fledgling oilmen, he borrowed enough money to purchase a couple of stripper leases and as his production grew, he began to drill his own wells. In 1980 and 1981, he drilled 89 wells. Over the years, Lester continued his oil business through Moore Engineering and Production Company, Inc., (Mepco), and Southern Triangle Oil Co. He had offices in Evansville and Mt. Carmel and an equipment yard in Grayville. He also operated a supply store in Crossville. Lester’s career in the Illinois Basin spanned over 60 years. He remained active to the end. With his technical knowledge, experience, and expertise, he stood out in leading the industry in development and operations. He was always available and generous with his technical advice.

Lester was a leader in the Industry in the states where his production was located and also on the national level. He was a supportive voice for the Industry and was able to clearly and intelligently articulate industry positions with legislators and regulators. He was a longtime member of the Illinois Oil and Gas Association, the Indiana Oil and Gas Association, Independent Oil Producers Association, Tri-State, and the Independent Petroleum Association of America. He took Industry battles to Washington, Springfield, Indianapolis, and all points in between. While strongly advocating for the Industry, Lester was always a gentleman. In commenting on his relationship with antagonistic politicians, Lester stated “You call on them and stay friendly. We try to impress upon them that we are ordinary people like they are.”

Lester was highly respected in the Industry. Barry Russell, the President and CEO of the Independent Petroleum Association of America stated “Lester was a strong part of the IPAA Volunteer Leadership for almost 40 years. It was a privilege to not only work closely with Lester on issues but also to consider him a close friend. On the board in those early days as well as at the time of his death, Lester was a tireless supporter of our Industry and of IPAA.” Craig R. Hedin, President of the IOGA, stated “Lester was one of my first clients in 1975. He was a most valuable mentor and friend for over 43 years – a great man. He would sit in meetings with his arms folded with that grin on his face. He would let everyone have their say and then he would speak his words of wisdom that cut right to the issue. He will be missed.” Mike Gibbons, Petroleum Engineer and former associate with Lester, was feeling stress on engineering a waterflood for Lester only to have it put into operation with oil at $9.00 a barrel. Lester advised that if oil prices did not come up within the next 6 to 12 months, it won’t matter because broke is broke and most small independents would be gone. His next bit of advice has stayed with Gibbons as he rose in the ranks to manage young engineering and geological staff over the years. Lester’s advice of “manage the things you can and cope with those things you cannot” has proven to be timeless.

Lester was an avid Fighting Illini fan, was a U.S. Navy Veteran, and a lifelong member of the Methodist Temple. Lester would be the first to credit his longtime employees for his success – Paul Hyatt, Whitman Myatt (a/k/a Unk), Stuart Davis, Wanda Embry, Charley Campbell, Ryan Bunnage, Melinda Sharp and Kelley Hoepner, all of Mepco; and Lynette Wiles and Roger Keen of Southern Triangle Oil Company. His associates have included, among others, Delwin Parker, Doug Reynolds, Jr., and Mike Gibbons.

Lester was preceded in death by his wife of 61 years, Joyce Moore, in 2017, and his parents. He is survived by his daughters, Leslie Hyland (Mike), Melinda Sharp (Jimmy), and Alyson Ross (Bennett); together with his grandchildren, Jennifer Kemling, Jeff Hyland, Stuart Davis, Jon Hyland, Jacob Ross, and Sam Ross; together with great-grandchildren, Payton, Carter, Cash, and Amelia; together with his brothers, Leroy Moore (Betty); and Chip Moore (Wilma). Lester is also survived by nieces, nephews, and cousins.

Funeral services for Lester were held on November 2, 2018, with burial in Bethel Cemetery in Ellery, Illinois. Memorial contributions may be made to the Methodist Temple in Evansville, Indiana, and the Bethel United Methodist Church in Ellery, Illinois, or to the donor’s favorite charity.

Farewell to an Industry Giant.